The Meraki Christmas Festival has been given planning permission by St Albans district council.
Last night, the planning referrals committee gave the go-ahead for the festival to take place on Verulamium Park - with strict conditions.
The site, the Front Meadow, must be reinstated to the state it was, grass and all, three months after the market finishes.
Despite 97 letters being sent to the council in support of the festival, there was some opposition, including from Green councillor Simon Grover, who said: “I am concerned about the music and noise aspect of this application.
“I would think it was possible to have a Christmas market here without constant loud music that would disturb neighbours and users of the park.”
Speaking as an objector to the festival application at the meeting was Peter Trevelyan, who spent much of his two-minute time limit attacking the planning officer responsible for presenting the application to councillors.
He said: “The case officer’s planning balance is wrong. She says it will cause harm to the Green Belt, but argues this is acceptable because of the economic benefit to the city centre.”
“But this is simply wrong. The proposal will be located over 800 metres from St Peter’s Street and retail development more than 500 metres from a city centre actually draws expenditure out of the nearby centre.”
Committee vice-chair Geoff Harrison responded: “I strongly respect Peter Trevelyan, but I think he has got it wrong on this occasion.
“I firmly believe this will be a great asset to the community.”
On concerns that market goers will not want to walk up Holywell Hill to visit the city centre, he said: “I am just waiting to go into hospital for a new knee and I put my body through stress to check what it would be like to go up and down Holywell Hill and I survived without a lot of painkillers, so I think the suggestion people will not go up and down the hill is very incorrect.”
Festival organiser Kerry Marks spoke in favour of the application and said: “We really need in the city something that more beautiful, more interactive and more fun.”
She said the festival was for “all incomes”, however several of the events at the event are priced.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules here