Driver convicted for fraud after making false insurance claim over St Albans pothole

PUBLISHED: 16:58 30 November 2018 | UPDATED: 17:06 30 November 2018

Robbie Beaton was convicted with fraud after making false insurance claims over a pothole on Coursers Road, Colney Heath, St Albans. Picture: Google Street View

Robbie Beaton was convicted with fraud after making false insurance claims over a pothole on Coursers Road, Colney Heath, St Albans. Picture: Google Street View


A man has been convicted of fraud for making a false insurance claim to Hertfordshire County Council over a pothole in St Albans.

Robbie Beaton, 45, of Dover Road, Walmer, Kent, claimed his car had been damaged by colliding with a pothole in Coursers Road, Colney Heath.

He appeared in St Albans Magistrates Court on Tuesday, November 27, to face charges of fraud by false representation.

The court heard that Beaton had falsified an invoice for work to support his damages claim against the council in June 2017. He increased the value of repairs required to his Audi TT in order to claim an insurance pay out of £4,214.24.

The council’s insurance team became suspicious of the claim, and the case was referred to the Shared Anti-Fraud Service to investigate.

An investigation revealed that Beaton had taken his car to a garage in Hatfield to be repaired and had used documents provided by the garage to create a false invoice with the cost increased.

When interviewed Beaton admitted he had made a false claim and falsified the documents. His damages claim was then withdrawn, preventing any payments being made to him, and the case was referred for prosecution.

Beaton pleaded guilty at the first opportunity, and the court heard he was of previous good character with no previous convictions. He apologised for his actions and said that he knew what he had done was wrong.

He was fined £1,600 and ordered to pay £2,000 in cots, as well as a £160 victim surcharge.

Cllr Ralph Sangster, cabinet member for resources, said: “This isn’t a victimless crime; fraudulent activity costs Hertfordshire local councils an enormous amount and adds to the already severe pressures on local services.

“We will actively pursue those unscrupulous people who think that they can defraud the county council and steal tax payers’ hard earned money.”

More news stories


Visitor and traders’ early reactions to St Albans’ highly -debated Christmas winter wonderland event have proved a mixed bag.


Police are warning residents against deliberately leaving their cars unlocked to stop property damage.


Village shoppers will be rewarded for staying local as part of a new loyalty scheme.

A new healthcare facility has been opened at St Albans City Hospital by the district mayor Rosemary Farmer.


I should probably have taken the hint! Walking out into the garden recently an unprecedented flock of thirty or more crows raucously greeted me from the treetops at the bottom of my garden. Cawing and croaking these big, black birds clung clumsily to the top most branches and twigs, jostling and flapping to stay balanced in a constant flurry of feathers. There is always something ominous about crows – they are after all carrion crows, the vultures of the bird world – always watching for scraps and weakness that might mean their next meal.

Digital Edition

Read the The Herts Advertiser e-edition E-edition
Zoo Watch CountryPhile

Newsletter Sign Up

Herts Advertiser weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Most read stories

Hot Jobs

Show Job Lists

Herts Most Wanted Herts Business Awards