Film Review: Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close
When Oskar’s Dad dies in the 9/11 attacks, he embarks on an unusual quest to reconnect with him.
Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close
Cert. 12A
3/5 stars
WHEN super-intelligent Oskar Schell’s Dad (Tom Hanks) dies in the World Trade centre attacks, the prodigious nine-year-old embarks on a city-wide search to reconnect with his departed parent by finding the lock that fits a single key found in his closet.
Oskar’s Mum (Sandra Bullock) and Grandma struggle to help Oskar heal as he submerges himself in the seemingly impossible task.
The meandering pace briefly picks up when Oskar’s Sherlock-esque capers kick-in, letting viewers share in his youthful excitement, but then all hope is lost when an anti-climactic twist dashes all hope of a resolution for our young hero.
Most Read
- 1 Armed police seize machete from Sandpit Lane in St Albans
- 2 Council confirms first monkeypox case in Hertfordshire
- 3 Police probe into death of man in 20s at 'Kinky Towers' in Hertfordshire
- 4 Rapist jailed for 15 years after kidnapping teen in Hemel Hempstead
- 5 Hertfordshire teen bullying victim given royal honour
- 6 Peregrine falcon chick hatches at St Albans Cathedral in a city first
- 7 Success for Harpenden actor after National Youth Theatre audition
- 8 St Albans SustFest events aim to boost local nature
- 9 5 things you might not have known about Herts county council's new chairman
- 10 The Crossrail connections to Hertfordshire which were never built
Hanks and Bullock put in predictably perfect performances, but the role of Oskar was also expertly cast, with real-life child prodigy (he won the children’s version of Jeopardy!) Thomas Horn, making his acting debut.
The emphasis on the events of 9/11 and the collective pain felt by the supporting New Yorkian characters is omnipresent and hard to relate to and, as a UK viewer, I definitely felt I was missing out on something.
Oskar could have lost his Dad in any circumstances and the story would have remained intact, but they’ve gone for the jugular with the relatively fresh (and sellable) Twin Towers tragedy.
I can imagine Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close being particularly affecting in print, making this yet another film adaptation that should perhaps have remained a quiet, personal experience on the page, rather than being turned into a blockbuster vehicle for Hanks and Bullock.
