St Albans passengers make discrimination claims over Thameslink carnet compensation controversy

PUBLISHED: 19:00 24 July 2018

Harpenden Train Station. Picture: DANNY LOO

Harpenden Train Station. Picture: DANNY LOO

©2018 Danny Loo Photography - all rights reserved

Thameslink passengers are complaining the lack of extra compensation for carnet ticket holders is sex discrimination.

Govia Thameslink Railway, which runs both Thameslink and Great Northern services, is helping fund a compensation scheme for season ticket holders caught up in this summer’s timetabling disruption.

But the scheme does not include day ticket holders, including people who buy multi-packs of single tickets called carnet, which has led to complaints of sex discrimination.

St Albans commuter and lawyer Isabel Martorell said: “It’s indirect sex discrimination because it’s having a disproportionate effect on part-time workers as people who use carnet tickets do not travel to London five days a week, who are predominately women.

“Under the Equality Act, this comes under the definition of sex discrimination.”

On the lack of extra compensation for day ticket holders, who have instead been asked to claim under the existing Delay Repay scheme, Isobel said: “It made me really angry as it added insult to injury.

“Working mothers suffer the most from train chaos because we struggle to juggle childcare and making nursery pick-ups and now we are being told we cannot get enhanced compensation.”

She has complained to Govia and also accosted a member of their staff at a Meet the Manager event at London Blackfriars station, who when told about the discrimination, admitted nobody had made that point when the scheme was being discussed.

A GTR spokesperson said: “The additional industry compensation scheme, which GTR is administering on behalf of the industry, has been offered to customers in agreement with the Department for Transport and in recognition of the recent disruption, for which we apologise.

“Season ticket holders, who bought a ticket for a specific length of time, are included in the new compensation scheme because they have experienced lengthy periods of disruption.

“Carnet tickets, where sold, are available to everyone, irrespective of gender therefore the decision not to include these in the compensation scheme is unlikely to amount to discrimination.”

More news stories


A 12th-century church in Flamstead has received a donation to help save its leaking roof and valuable wall paintings.

Yesterday, 15:15

Police are investigating following a crash this morning between Welwyn Hatfield and Wheathampstead which has put a motorcyclist in hospital with life-threatening injuries.

Yesterday, 12:00

A St Albans club for dementia sufferers has raised £4,522 to continue its work.

Yesterday, 09:00

A corrupt Victorian lawyer is at the centre of the latest installment of Harpenden author Carol Hedges’ acclaimed murder mystery series.


A few years back I was fixing a shed in our garden and had enlisted the help of my young son. We were busy moving rotten pieces of wood from the side of the shed when suddenly I felt sharp stabbing pains in my lower legs. Before I had a chance to investigate my son started screaming in pain and it took a few more seconds to realize that we were trampling on a wasps’ nest!

Digital Edition

Read the The Herts Advertiser e-edition E-edition
Zoo Watch CountryPhile

Newsletter Sign Up

Herts Advertiser weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Most read stories

Show Job Lists

Herts Most Wanted Herts Business Awards