St Albans MP demands action over asbestos-related cancer

17:00 11 January 2016

Fred Minall, 74, formerly of Wheathampstead, served on destroyers with the Royal Navy, and has been diagnosed with the incurable asbestos-related lung disease, mesothelioma.

Fred Minall, 74, formerly of Wheathampstead, served on destroyers with the Royal Navy, and has been diagnosed with the incurable asbestos-related lung disease, mesothelioma.

Photo supplied

Although the Government has recently bowed to pressure to better compensate veterans with asbestos-related cancer, St Albans MP Anne Main wants more action on the contentious issue.

Armed Forces veteran Fed Minall worked aboard HMS Trafalgar, seen here in 1959Armed Forces veteran Fed Minall worked aboard HMS Trafalgar, seen here in 1959

Until recently, an absurd situation existed where personnel who were exposed to the potentially deadly fibre while in the Armed Forces prior to 1987 and have since been diagnosed with the terminal lung cancer mesothelioma, could not claim compensation comparable to their civilian counterparts.

Among those fighting for a fairer deal is a former Wheathampstead man who is facing a death sentence 60 years after working with asbestos-ridden material while in the Navy.

Fred Minall, 74, approached the Herts Advertiser to help warn fellow veterans in Hertfordshire that they, like him, could end up being diagnosed with the incurable asbestos-related lung disease.

Along with the Royal British Legion, Fred has successfully spearheaded a campaign to help secure pay-outs for thousands of veterans.

Armed Forces veteran Fed Minall, originally of Wheathampstead, who has spearheaded the asbestos fair pay campaignArmed Forces veteran Fed Minall, originally of Wheathampstead, who has spearheaded the asbestos fair pay campaign

He and the Legion told politicians it was unfair that compensation rules meant veterans developing mesothelioma from working with asbestos during service could be left £150,000 worse off than their civilian counterparts.

The introduction of the 1987 (Armed Forces) Act allowed the Ministry of Defence (MoD) to be exempt from responsibility regarding any veteran’s exposure to asbestos, which resulted in people like Fred being isolated and ignored.

However, just before Christmas, the Government announced a U-turn on the unfair compensation rules, saying that all veterans diagnosed with mesothelioma on or after December 16, 2015, would be given the choice between receiving a traditional War Pension, or £140,000 in lump sum compensation.

The British Legion’s director general Chris Simpkins welcomed the change, but added, “we remain disappointed that around 60 veterans who are currently in receipt of a War Disablement Pension for mesothelioma will be unable to apply for the new lump sum compensation award.”

Anne Main said she also welcomed the government’s correction of, “the ridiculous inequality between veterans and civilians.

“It cannot be right that those with mesothelioma who have bravely served their country are entitled to less money than anybody else. We must recognise the difficulties faced by everyone who is affected by this type of cancer.”

But, she said: “Clearly, there is more that can be done. I’ve asked if the new scheme will be extended to those on the War Disablement Pension. There are currently around 60 veterans who fall into this category who are unable to apply for the new compensation award.

“It is extremely important that members of the Armed Forces face no disadvantage simply because of military service.”

It is understood that around three or four veterans in Hertfordshire are diagnosed with the incurable lung disease at any one time.

Fred Minall grew up in Wheathampstead and attended St. Helen’s CE Primary School in the village.

His mother, Mary Minall, was very active in the British Legion and Fred, upon leaving home at the age of 15, joined the Royal Navy in 1957.

In mid-1958 Fred went aboard the first of four destroyers, and in the following eight years he worked in the engine and boiler rooms. Unfortunately, his work as a mechanical engineer meant that he would regularly remove and renew asbestos-related heat insulation material from machinery and steam pipes during repair and maintenance. Dust and debris from asbestos material would penetrate his overalls and cover his head, hair and body.

Fred, who has been undergoing chemotherapy treatment, said he was concerned for fellow veterans, including those who attended school with him and joined the Navy, who might have also unknowingly developed the fatal disease.

The primary aim of his campaign was to encourage the MoD to identify and make proper payment to current and potential sufferers of mesothelioma, in order that they might seek compensation.


Welcome , please leave your message below.

Optional - JPG files only
Optional - MP3 files only
Optional - 3GP, AVI, MOV, MPG or WMV files

Please log in to leave a comment and share your views with other Herts Advertiser visitors.

We enable people to post comments with the aim of encouraging open debate.

Only people who register and sign up to our terms and conditions can post comments. These terms and conditions explain our house rules and legal guidelines.

Comments are not edited by Herts Advertiser staff prior to publication but may be automatically filtered.

If you have a complaint about a comment please contact us by clicking on the Report This Comment button next to the comment.

Not a member yet?

Register to create your own unique Herts Advertiser account for free.

Signing up is free, quick and easy and offers you the chance to add comments, personalise the site with local information picked just for you, and more.

Sign up now

More news stories

Herts Advertiser 10 years ago October 19, 2006

Police and paramedics rushed to the scene of a terrifying CS gas attack on a bus packed with schoolchildren, a report in the Herts Advertiser said 10 years ago.

Thameslink train

A grievance-airing session involving passengers and representatives of train and rail companies has led St Albans MP Anne Main to express the hope that there is ‘light at the end of the tunnel’.

ID shot of Prae Wood School

A police investigation is underway at a St Albans primary school following allegations of theft from the PTA accounts.

Milo was last seen three days ago.

The search is on to find a beloved St Albans cat which has been missing for three days.

Save a trip to your local GP with the free prescription service at Avicenna Pharmacy

Avicenna in St Albans offers a FREE repeat prescription collection and delivery service.


Could there be a Beast of Hertfordshire? Residents have reported seeing a panther (file photo) in Harpenden and Hitchin

Reports of recent panther sightings in the St Albans district have been reinforced by the founder of a big cat sanctuary, who said a puma has also been seen roaming near this area.

Digital Edition

Read the The Herts Advertiser e-edition E-edition
Zoo Watch CountryPhile

St Albans Sinkhole News

Friday, October 7, 2016
David Walker lives near the sinkhole in Fontmell Close, St Albans. This photo was taken after most of the cavity was filled with special concrete to plug it.

The Herts Advertiser has been visiting residents in St Albans to see how they have been coping one year after the sinkhole appeared in Fontmell Close on October 1, 2015, in a series of articles to mark the first anniversary of the collapse.

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to the following newsletters:

Most read stories

Local business directory

Hertfordshire's trusted business finder

Show Job Lists

Herts Most Wanted Herts Business Awards