Chiswell Green gardener issued fine for driving in bus lane in car he no longer owned

PUBLISHED: 12:42 21 August 2012

LAW-abiding head gardener Andy Godly has found himself in a Catch 22 situation after being accused of driving in a bus lane in a car which was no longer his.

Andy, 46, who has been head gardener at the Gardens of the Rose in Chiswell Green for the past few years, gave away the Nissan Micra which had been sitting on his drive at his home in Dunstable last October.

The following day he notified the DVLA about the change of ownership – and thought no more about it.

But shortly afterwards he received a letter from Luton borough council saying he had driven through a bus lane in Bury Park.

Andy contacted the council to say he was no longer the owner and that if they contacted the DVLA, they would give them the name of the new owner – which they refused to do saying it was not a requirement for them.

When he found he was still being pursued for the fine, Andy appealed to a traffic penalty tribunal which ruled against him, saying it was his responsibility to give them the details of the new owner.

But he had already contacted the DVLA himself and was told to get the council to write to them and they would be given the details of the new owner.

The council subsequently obtained a county court order against Andy and since earlier this year, he has been threatened with bailiffs entering his home and taking his property in lieu of a fine he did not incur.

Andy, who previously lived in Redbourn and Wheathampstead, said this week: “It is a stupid Catch 22 situation which is like something out of Yes Minister.”

He pointed out that had if it been a speeding offence, he could have gone to court over the issue but it would not have been necessary because the police would have checked with the DVLA.

He went on: “I thought you were innocent until proved guilty not guilty until proved innocent.”

South Beds MP Andrew Selous has taken up Andy’s case and has now obtained a letter from the DVLA confirming that he had notified them immediately that he was no longer the owner after the car changed hands.

But Andy is still worried that until the county court order is lifted, he could still come home to find bailiffs taking his property.

He added: “The council’s attitude is that once you have been through their appeals procedure that is it. It is in black and white that they are right and you are wrong.”

Luton borough council was unmoved this week by Mr Selous obtaining confirmation from the DVLA that Andy had notified them about the change of ownership by the time the offence happened.

They maintained that as he had not provided any evidence at the time of the tribunal, the independent adjudicator’s decision was final and the only route left to Andy was a judicial review of the evidence presented to the tribunal.

A statement from the council added: “There is nothing more the council can do and Mr Godly remains liable to pay the Penalty Charge Notice.”

More news stories


Traffic is queueing on the M1 following a crash between a car and motorcyclist in the St Albans area.


A St Albans baker’s cake has been taste-tested on national television by famous actors.

A group of families have taken part in this year’s Children in Need appeal to help highlight the work of Rennie Grove Hospice Care.


Being ill sucks. No matter what’s got you down – the flu, a broken bone, diabetes, cancer – it’s a horrible place to be. Your body is weaker and less capable. The drugs you take mess with your mind and your moods and sometimes can make you feel even worse than when you started. Mental ill-health is no different. The brain is an organ, and like any organ, it doesn’t always function to the medical standard of “normal”. Mine certainly doesn’t.


Recently we, as a family (minus two of the kids), visited The Lodge RSPB reserve in Sandy, Bedfordshire. I had never been before, which is perhaps amiss of me as a birdwatcher as it is the headquarters of the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds or RSPB and only 45 minutes drive from home.

Digital Edition

Read the The Herts Advertiser e-edition E-edition
Zoo Watch CountryPhile

Newsletter Sign Up

Herts Advertiser weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Most read stories

Show Job Lists

Herts Most Wanted Herts Business Awards